Hard times: Investigating the archaeology of a 19th-century workhouse

This spring marked 300 years since the introduction of the 1723 Workhouse Test Act, often seen as the origin of the workhouse system in England and Wales. These institutions were designed as refuges for the destitute, but ultimately became a byword for cruelty and neglect. What can archaeology add to our understanding of the experiences of those who lived and worked in them? Carly Hilts reports on how recent excavations in London have illuminated one such site.

When we hear the word ‘workhouse’, many of us will be immediately transported in our imaginations to the world of Charles Dickens; to dingy Victorian institutions, overcrowded and disease-ridden; to uncaring masters and matrons doling out harsh punishments; and to a starving scrap of a child holding out a bowl in the forlorn hope of a second serving of watery gruel. Nineteenth-century novelists and social reformers alike decried this system of ‘support’ for society’s most vulnerable members, and we have a wealth of written references, records, and reports to help build a vivid account of the conditions under which these infamous institutions operated. Was this situation always so bleak, however – and what can archaeology add to the picture? Recent excavations close to St Pancras Station in London have revealed the well-preserved remains of a workhouse that stood on the site for more than 100 years – and evidence that, in its early days at least, the building’s governors did show some care for the comfort of its inhabitants.

Part of the excavated remains of the St Pancras Workhouse; these small rooms were probably used to store coal. Image: © MOLA
A fragment of institutional pottery from the site. Image: © MOLA

When the St Pancras Workhouse opened its doors in 1809, it was the third such institution to appear in the area. Its predecessors, founded in the mid-18th century and operating out of rented buildings, soon succumbed to overcrowding and disrepair; the new workhouse, however, had been accorded purpose-built facilities, designed to accommodate 500 of the most vulnerable of the local population. Three years later, it added an infirmary – a vital resource for its inhabitants, who would otherwise have had no recourse to free medical care (the NHS would not be founded for another 136 years) – but while the workhouse repeatedly expanded over the course of its existence, the numbers of urban poor continued to soar, and the institution could not keep pace with this growing need.

By the 1850s, the site had become drastically overcrowded, housing between 1,500 and 1,900 poor, sick, and mentally unwell individuals, and official records of the conditions in which they were housed became increasingly condemnatory. Nevertheless, the St Pancras Workhouse continued to operate until 1929, when it became the St Pancras Hospital. Some of its original buildings are still in use, today part of the Camden and Islington NHS Foundation Trust, though many did not survive to the present, having been demolished either during historical extensions and alterations to the workhouse complex, or following bomb damage during the Second World War. Now, with a new health facility set to be built on the site, MOLA (Museum of London Archaeology) have brought some of these lost elements to light once more.

Features Imperial impact: Illuminating Icenian interactions with Rome at Caistor St Edmund
Features The Klein Hollandia: Discovering a 17th-century Dutch warship off Eastbourne