Witch hunting and trials in early modern Europe left behind a dense paper trail of judgements, confessions, sermons, treatises, and sentences. They also left bodies. For centuries, the official theological and legal records have shaped how we imagine these trials and executions. Officially, the condemned were to be strangled or decapitated before the flames were lit, so that burning was an act of purification as much as punishment. In this official account, justice was severe, but also morally grounded. Mercy was repeatedly invoked as the separation between lawful punishment and cruelty; the body might be destroyed, but the suffering of the condemned was, at least in theory, to be limited.
Centuries later, however, that controlled image has started to break. When archaeologists recover skeletal remains from sites linked to suspected witches, the evidence does not always support the story preserved in the official written records. Instead, osteological analysis and burial evidence can point to trauma and post-mortem treatment that reveal execution as a far messier and more violent process than the early modern authorities wished to admit.

The historical record documents the execution of numerous people accused of witchcraft in early modern Europe, with this image showing events at Willisau, Switzerland, in 1447. Burning became the most recognisable visual shorthand for witch execution, even if the legal records claim that the condemned were first strangled or decapitated. Such images present execution as spectacle: communal, visible, and framed as lawful punishment. While the written accounts typically frame these executions as an act of mercy and purification, the archaeology suggests otherwise. Image: public domain via Wikimedia Commons
Language of justice
To understand why this contradiction matters, it is important to recognise how witch hunts were presented within their context. Across early modern Europe, witch prosecutions were framed within a language of law and religion that was tied to a moral duty. Far from being seen as excessively violent, they were often described as expressions of justice itself. Legal codes and religious texts emphasised that punishment should be carried out with decency and restraint, reinforcing the idea that, even in death, the accused were afforded a degree of compassion.








