Lapis Lazuli, The Blue Road: Seeking the sources of the longest trade

Establishing the origin of the lapis lazuli used in ancient artefacts has long been beyond the reach of science. Now an innovative technique has revealed, in a non-invasive way, where the precious stone was coming from. Alessandro Lo Giudice, Alessandro Re, Laura Guidorzi, Marta Magalini, Norman Hammond, Randall Law, Guy Clutterbuck, and Georgina Herrmann guide us from a laboratory in Italy to a remote mine.

The semi-precious stone, lapis lazuli, has been prized for its bright blue colour from at least as early as the 5th millennium BC, and is still valued today. However, apart from its colour and its long popularity, what is of particular importance about this stone is that it is only found in a few places in the world, including Badakhshan in north-east Afghanistan and Chile in South America. Today, lapis lazuli is best known for its use as a pigment in Renaissance Italy, where it was ground up and purified to form deep, true-blue ultramarine, one of the costliest and most precious of painting materials. Even so, lapis lazuli was valued for its colour and its perceived ability to protect its owner from evil through the millennia. Such desirable qualities made the stone an important raw material for artefacts manufactured by numerous ancient cultures. Tracing that lapis lazuli to its true source(s) promised important insights into ancient exchange networks, but achieving this goal has proven to be fraught with difficulties.

 Lapis lazuli was used in a wealth of objects from the ancient world. Here we see a detail from the renowned ‘Standard of Ur’, which was found in the Royal Cemetery by Leonard Woolley. The Standard features decoration on four sides and dates to the mid-3rd millennium BC. The scenes include this representation of men bringing in animals, perhaps as tribute. Such images were created using materials including limestones, shell, and lapis lazuli. Despite the importance of this semi-precious stone, for many decades it has frustrated attempts to track it to a specific source. Image: © The Trustees of the British Museum

Provenance investigation

It has long been assumed that the lapis lazuli extensively used in ancient Mesopotamia and Egypt came from the Afghan source at Badakhshan, where the finest quality lapis lazuli is found, despite its remoteness. However, while this was the most probable source, for a long time it has proved impossible to demonstrate this scientifically by means of non-invasive techniques. This is in large part due to the complex composition of the stone. While the blue colour is created by lazurite, the lapis lazuli itself is an aggregate of different minerals, whose presence and abundances can vary considerably; this quality is reflected in its wide range of colours. Due to the heterogeneity of lapis lazuli, it is very difficult to identify provenance markers by analysing the whole stone. Moreover, large sets of reference rocks with a reliable source attribution are difficult to find due to the general inaccessibility of the mines and the lack of accurate geographical information on specimens stored in museums and private collections.

Now, though, a team of scientists from the University of Turin and the INFN Turin Division (Italy) has finally achieved this goal by developing a new methodology based on non-invasive advanced scientific techniques, called ion beam analyses. Using small proton accelerators available in different European laboratories, it is possible to analyse the properties of the lapis lazuli material down to the micrometric scale. This allowed the team to identify chemical and physical features within the single crystals of individual mineral phases (a few hundred microns in size), which can be used as a provenance fingerprint. In fact, lapis lazuli from different parts of the world has peculiar chemical properties due to some differences in the mechanism of mineral formation. In the last 15 years, the Turin team has analysed a large number of reference rocks (almost 70 to date) from five different source areas: Chile (Coquimbo region), Afghanistan (Badakhshan region), Tajikistan (Lyadzhvardara, Pamir Mountains), Siberia (Lake Baikal area), and Myanmar (Mogok region). Several characteristic trace elements or luminescence properties have been identified to distinguish between these lapis lazuli sources. These same markers can be searched in lapis lazuli artefacts and compared with the reference dataset to infer the provenance of the raw material used to create the analysed object.

Features The Hoby cups: Tracing connections in Iron Age Denmark
Features Viterbo: Early conclaves and a papal palace