Above Side by side in a pit, these skeletons were originally assumed to be Black Death victims, but radiocarbon dates have provided an unexpected explanation for the high fatality rate. Could they have died as a result of the last millennium’s largest volcanic eruption? This mass burial clips the edge of an earlier pit that may date to a 1252 famine, while the bodies in the later pit are believed to be victims of the climatic fluctuation brought on by the 1258 eruption.

London’s volcanic winter: Spitalfields cemetery and the famine of 1258

Mass graves were needed all too often in the Medieval world, but establishing the specific tragedy behind any given set is difficult. Now Don Walker believes that a group in Spitalfields cemetery can be linked to a massive volcanic eruption, as he told Matthew Symonds.

The destructive force unleashed by Vesuvius, Krakatoa, and Mount St Helens made those volcanoes household names. Yet all three are dwarfed by the largest eruption of the last millennium. It violently ejected between 200 and 600 megatons of sulphate into the Earth’s atmosphere, around eight times the yield from Krakatoa. Probably occurring in early 1258 AD, this was an eruption on a cataclysmic scale.

left An 1888 impression of the 1883 Krakatoa eruption. This is believed to have killed over 36,000 people. On the basis of ice cores and sediments in Lake Malawi, Krakatoa was dwarfed by the 1258 eruption.
An 1888 impression of the 1883 Krakatoa eruption. This is believed to have killed over 36,000 people. On the basis of ice cores and sediments in Lake Malawi, Krakatoa was dwarfed by the 1258 eruption. Image: The Royal Society.

Despite its magnitude, the identity of the volcano responsible remains a mystery. El Chichón in Mexico, Quilotoa in Ecuador, and, most recently, a site in Indonesia have all been named as possible culprits. But while the source of the sulphates remains elusive, the eruption’s fingerprints can be found around the globe. Ice cores from both the northern hemisphere and Antarctica preserve its debris, while a thick layer of ash lies among the sediments in Lake Malawi, nestled between Mozambique and Tanzania. Traces can even be found in the records of contemporary chroniclers writing far from the tropics.

Above Side by side in a pit, these skeletons were originally assumed to be Black Death victims, but radiocarbon dates have provided an unexpected explanation for the high fatality rate. Could they have died as a result of the last millennium’s largest volcanic eruption? This mass burial clips the edge of an earlier pit that may date to a 1252 famine, while the bodies in the later pit are believed to be victims of the climatic fluctuation brought on by the 1258 eruption.
Side by side in a pit, these skeletons were originally assumed to be Black Death victims, but radiocarbon dates have provided an unexpected explanation for the high fatality rate. Could they have died as a result of the last millennium’s largest volcanic eruption? This mass burial clips the edge of an earlier pit that may date to a 1252 famine, while the bodies in the later pit are believed to be victims of the climatic fluctuation brought on by the 1258 eruption.

The unseasonableness of the atmosphere

Wherever the volcano lay, Matthew Paris was living thousands of miles away when it blew – a Benedictine monk writing in St Albans abbey. His Historia Anglorum covers the period from 1250-1259, and intersperses commentary on contemporary events with observations on that most British of obsessions: the weather. Paris was perplexed and troubled by what he saw in 1258. The year got off to a bad start, with the monk recording ‘such unendurable cold, that it bound up the face of the earth, sorely afflicted the poor, suspended all cultivation, and killed the young of the cattle’. But that was just the beginning. As the year progressed the situation deteriorated, and by midsummer Paris had cause to put pen to parchment once more:

Comment The best degree?