Deducing a date

A heritage tragedy led to the identification of the earliest known photograph in the HEIR archive, as Janice Kinory reveals.

An early lantern-slide image of Notre-Dame Cathedral, Paris, France.

A frequent question for the HEIR Project digital image archive is which is our oldest picture. We discovered the answer unexpectedly. On 15 April 2019, the world learned of the extensive damage at Notre-Dame due to the fire. The collapse of the spire was heart-breaking to watch. Wanting to post a cathedral image on social media, we reviewed our pictures of the building exterior and realised that one of them had no spire.

Had the original negative been altered? Why would the spire have been removed from the image? Even if this had happened, the right-hand tower, having originally been partially obscured by the now-destroyed spire from this angle, would not appear as it does. It was too tantalising a mystery to leave unresolved. We began with a review of the history of the spire, after a suggestion from an HEIR volunteer.

By the 18th century, the original 13th-century spire, made of wood with a lead covering, had warped and was leaning dangerously, so it was removed in stages between 1786 and 1792. However, it was the French Revolution, begun in 1789, with its anti-monarchical and anti-clerical beliefs, that was the most destructive to the cathedral. In 1791, 19 of the 20 church bells were removed and melted down to make cannons. Many statues on the exterior were damaged or destroyed, though the medieval Virgin Mary survived. The interior of the building was stripped of its Christian identity, converted into a secular space, and used as a warehouse.

Features The evidence of bones: The bioarchaeology of early modern European witch hunts