The ‘bluidy’ battle of Killiecrankie: excavating the first Jacobite Rising

What can archaeological surveys of battlefields add to historical accounts of the fighting? Road improvements at Killiecrankie provided an opportunity to see how traces of fighting tallied with a commanding officer’s account of the clash, as Maureen Kilpatrick and Warren Bailie report.

Journeying north up the A9 between Pitlochry and Blair Atholl in the Scottish Highlands, most travellers are unaware that they are driving through the centre of a battlefield. But if they were transported 327 years back in time, to their left they might have seen the red-coated line of a Government army and to the right three columns of charging Highlanders. Despite being divided by a major road, Killiecrankie is one of the best-preserved battlefields in Scotland. Archaeological fieldwork in 2015 revealed new evidence for the location of the fighting that saw a Jacobite army of Highlanders overwhelm a numerically superior Government force.

main image Re-enactment of a Highland charge during the annual Soldiers of Killiecrankie event (see box p.46). Despite it seeming to involve little more than a disorderly rush at the enemy, the charge required great discipline. During the battle such a charge smashed the left flank of the Government army.
Re-enactment of a Highland charge during the annual Soldiers of Killiecrankie event (see box p.46). Despite it seeming to involve little more than a disorderly rush at the enemy, the charge required great discipline. During the battle such a charge smashed the left flank of the Government army. Photo: NTS.

Came ye by Killicrankie, O?

Fought on 27 July 1689, the battle at Killiecrankie was the opening clash of the first Jacobite Rising, which followed the tumultuous events of 1688, when James VII (or James II of England) – the last Catholic King to reign over Scotland, England, Wales, and Ireland – was ousted and replaced in England by the Protestant William of Orange and Queen Mary, James’s own daughter. In 1689, the Scottish Parliament voted to give the crown of Scotland to William and Mary. In response, John Graham of Claverhouse, Viscount Dundee, raised an army under the standard of James VII. Dundee’s army mainly comprised Scottish Highlanders, supported by a small force of Irish troops. To counter this, a Government army of Lowland Scottish, English, and Dutch forces was raised, led by Major General Hugh Mackay, who wrote an eye-witness account of the battle.

left The location of the Killiecrankie battlefield, with the modern A9 road passing directly between the former Jacobite and Government army positions at the opening of the engagement.
The location of the Killiecrankie battlefield, with the modern A9 road passing directly between the former Jacobite and Government army positions at the opening of the engagement. Photo: GUARD Archaeology Ltd.

The battle came at the end of a cat-and-mouse chase around the Highlands, as Mackay and Dundee each tried to gain an advantage over the other and bring their opponent to a decisive battle. In July 1689, both were heading for Blair Atholl to capture the castle there, which they intended to use as a base. ‘Bonnie Dundee’, as he was dubbed by Sir Walter Scott, or ‘Bluidy Clavers’ to his Covenanter enemies, was coming south with around 2,400 men, while Mackay was marching north with a much larger army of between 3,500 and 5,000 men. It was on the slopes of Creag Eallaich, at the Pass of Killiecrankie, a gorge formed by the River Garry on the key communications route into the Highlands from Perth to Inverness, that the two armies met.