After more than 50 columns exploring the archaeology of the British Isles through a geographic lens, I begin here a new thematic focus: that of ‘great’ sites visited by Current Archaeology down the years. As I neared the end of my tour of the four nations, I reflected on the enduring power of a ‘great’ site. Sometimes it is the physical presence of a location (Maiden Castle springs to mind here); other times, it is the discoveries made (think of Sutton Hoo, whose treasures never fail to awe). But in some cases ‘greatness’ is more subtle: a site can be ‘great’ without having much to see above ground, and its significance may only become clear after years of analysis. It is with these thoughts in mind that I commence with Star Carr, near Scarborough in North Yorkshire. Discovered in 1947 by amateur archaeologist John Moore (and subject to fieldwork in 1949-1951 by Grahame Clark, 1985-1997 by Tim Schadla-Hall and Paul Mellars, and since the early 2000s by Nicky Milner, Chantal Conneller, and Barry Taylor), Star Carr’s claim to greatness is straightforward: it is consistently considered to be the most important and informative Mesolithic site in the whole of Great Britain.
Current Archaeology has visited Star Carr regularly across the decades, commencing in CA 26 (May 1971), reporting on a conference on British prehistory that included a presentation from Grahame Clark about the seasonal population density anticipated at the site. CA 48 (January 1975) followed up with more on this theory, and CA 153 (July 1997) updated the story with the latest thinking on the subject some 20 years later. The wider legacy of Grahame Clark’s thinking about the site is then explored in CA 155 (December 1997), reporting on a symposium in his memory following his death aged 88 in 1995.
Mesolithic menageries
The 1990s and early 2000s saw a change of focus in CA’s reporting on Star Carr, moving away from the previously dominant theories of Grahame Clark. New studies of materials from the site and its comparators were linked to the latest scientific analysis, including that of the evidence for dogs from the site: the oldest known dog remains in the UK being one of Star Carr’s multiple claims to greatness. The research included analysis of their primarily fish-based diets, as reported in CA 124 (May 1991). (For those of you curious of this subject, see also CA 301, April 2015, about the wider archaeology of dogs down the ages.) CA 210 (July 2007) then reported on the evidence for beavers from this and other sites, and CA 229 (April 2009) examined how the dogs may have hunted – and the beavers been hunted – revealing a sophisticated social structure evidenced by close-range stalking strategy attacks by individual predators as opposed to a larger group stampede.






